Have you ever wondered why children act the way they do or why certain behaviors persist despite efforts to redirect them? Sometimes, despite trying various strategies, it may feel as though “nothing is working.” However, taking a step back to explore the motivations behind these behaviors is key to effectively changing them.
One reason for persistent behaviors is that the processes driving them are often subconscious. Children may not be able to express what they need or how an adult’s response is meeting or not meeting those needs. As a result, the responsibility falls on caregivers to explore the root cause of these behaviors and adapt their responses.
REINFORCEMENT
Reinforcement plays a crucial role in behavior modification. However, caregivers sometimes unintentionally reinforce undesirable behavior with their responses. For example, if the adult’s approach meets the need from which it originated, giving negative attention (yelling, lecturing, engaging) or granting avoidance (grounding, sending away, delaying a task) could lead a child to repeat the behavior even more. To break this cycle, it’s essential to reevaluate how the behavior is currently being responded to.
Instead of punishing problem behaviors, well-constructed positive reinforcement systems focus caregivers’ attention on the habits and attitudes they want to encourage rather than what they want to eliminate. This simple but powerful shift in perspective can help parents and educators encourage children to make healthier decisions, strengthen adult-child relationships, and promote self-esteem.
When it comes to any repeated action that derives from a subconscious need, the bottom line is this: the behavior will likely continue until the need is met in some other way. After identifying a potential cause, the first step is to create an alternate pathway that still meets that need (ie. becoming the “class helper” and receiving frequent praise to meet the need for attention), and then consistently reinforce the new, desirable behaviors.
ATTENTION AS A MOTIVATOR
Children’s intrinsic need for attention is natural, expected, and healthy; however, they are learning how to express this need in prosocial ways. Sometimes, problematic attention-seeking behavior is immediately evident, such as disruptive noise-making in class or constantly interrupting others’ conversations. On the other hand, defiance, aggression, and running away may appear to be motivated by a desire for escape, but they could also be driven by a subconscious pattern that recognizes negative attention as preferable to no attention at all.
For example, if a child is struggling with defiance and a need for attention may be the cause, the first step a caregiver can take is to stop the unintentional reinforcement of that defiance by no longer acknowledging or engaging with it as much as possible. However, an alternate pathway for meeting the need must be consistently presented and heavily reinforced before, during, and after. This generally includes giving frequent and immediate attention to all non-defiant behavior, until the defiance is replaced with a newly learned pathway that addresses the original need.
AVOIDANCE AS A MOTIVATOR
Avoidance behavior is generally recognized as any action taken to escape a particular task or situation. Examples include outright defiance, shutting down/withdrawal, leaving the room, ignoring directions, disruptive tantrums, and being off-task. Understanding the "why" behind the avoidance behavior (e.g., sensory overload, fear of failure) is crucial for customizing interventions to each unique child and situation. Anxiety and discomfort both play a role in avoidance behavior, so an intervention for this motivator will look very different than what is required for attention.
One approach to dealing with avoidance is harnessing the power of choice to restore a sense of autonomy and encourage self-led task completion. Two other common strategies are gradual, repeated exposure to the task or situation with support and reinforcement (also known as desensitization) and teaching the communication skills needed to express discomfort without turning to avoidant behaviors. No matter the method, positive reinforcement plays a major role in encouraging the completion of whatever is being avoided.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Identifying the root cause of a behavior can help guide children to make healthier decisions.
Reinforcement given to undesirable behaviors that could be unintentionally meeting the need for attention or avoidance should be withheld.
Alternative ways to meet the need (ie. the need for attention must be met with attention) should be clearly provided and continuously reinforced.
For avoidance behaviors, some common effective strategies include providing choice, using positive reinforcement, desensitization, and strengthening communication skills.
Written by Brandi R.